HICDEP Development (#1) - Name of tblAE (#54) - Message List
In our last telephone conference, we noted that the name of tblAE may not be the best fit, as it contains not only adverse events, but also clinical procedures and non-adverse events.
Hence we propose to rename tblAE to tblCEP (Clinical Events and Procedures). To keep the column names consistent, we would rename AE_D, AE_ID, AE_SPEC to CEP_D, CEP_ID, CEP_SPEC (and do the same to the optional fields).
In the coding table of the field AE_ID (CEP_ID)(http://www.hicdep.org/wiki/Hicdep_1.70/TableAe/FieldAeId#CodingTable) we would separate procedures from events (we identified so far: END, FIBS, LIVB, ANG, CERC).
Any comments to this?
PS: The draft-release of Hicdep 1.70 is not too far away. If you have any other comments to make that should go into this release, speak out soon :)
I don't see the need to rename. Surely any clinical event that may befall a patient - og any procedure - would by definition be ADVERSE .. i.e. to the detriment of the patient??rsb@…09/05/13 13:48:56 (4 years ago)
I am not in favour of renaming the table AE into CEP. I'd rather not collect Adverse Events and medical procedures in the same table.
Let's keep in line with the current practice of many cohorts in EuroCOORD and collect in the tblAE only (serious) adverse events defined as "Any untoward medical occurrence in a patient or clinical investigation subject administered a pharmaceutical product and which does not necessarily have a causal relationship with this treatment".
Medical or diagnostical procedures do not belong in the AE table as these procedures are planned. Undesirable or harmful effects, such as infection, hemorrhage, inflammation, scarring, loss of function, or changes in local blood due to(surgical) procedure can be registred in the AE table but not the procedure itsself.
Thus, transfer medical procedures like END, FIBS, LIVB, ANG, CERC to a new table and keep the table AE for adverse events only, using the here above ICH-GCP definition for adverse events.
I think it keeps things more simple and it is more logical from a data manager point of view.
Moniquemtermote09/05/13 16:41:03 (4 years ago)
also found the description AE somewhat counterintuitive since the events also occur in patients not receiving any pharmaceutical product. Some other wishes/comments: Hodgkin’s disease is still found in the AE and DIS table (to be deleted there?). Events categorized as CDC B are found in AE and DIS tables (visceral leishmaniasis in DIS; cercical dysplasia in AE (NADM), if this remains so, fine, however cervical dysplasia should be grade 2 or higher. Will anal dysplasia be added? (also grade 2 or higher). I miss head and neck cancer (related to smoking and HPV), to a lesser extent brain cancer?
There is also the question to add severe infections not listed in the DIS table, one example is penicilliosis, which occurs not infrequently in patients from south-east asia (and may be seen like visceral leishmaniais). Also other severe infections (requiring hospitalisation) might be worthwhile (from EuroSIDA: BACT=Bacteremia, ENDO=Endocarditis, MENI=Meningitis, OSTI: Ostitis, PERI: Peritonitis, PNEU=Pneumonia, PYEL=Pyelonephritis, Other?)
Procedures and events in the same table is a frequent phenomenon in the clinics, however ANG, BYP and END may be better listed only as a _SPEC variable (whereas ICP is a _ID variable).
Robertzangro09/08/13 21:22:19 (4 years ago)
Ok, lets summarize your proposed changes (not regarding the name of tblAE):
- Remove HG (HG - Hodgkins Lymphoma) from tblDIS
- Change the description of NADM-CERV to contain "grade 2 or higher" (http://www.hicdep.org/wiki/Hicdep_1.70/TableAe/FieldAeSpec FieldAeSpec)
- Regarding Cancer reporting: There is currently a group working on it. So I suggest we wait on the results.
- Add severe infections to tblDIS
- Remove ANG,BYP,END from AE_ID coding (strangely, there is already a code under AE_SPEC ICP...). As they are basically duplicates now, I think we should definitely remove them.
Any comments? I would suggest waiting on the cancer related changes and add the other changes.
Cheers Lukashumlu09/16/13 12:22:05 (4 years ago)